News    Please click the Current Issue button above to return to the contents page
 
Dispute as rival groups publish details of human genome
 
Scientists plan human cloning clinic in the United States
 
WHO disappoints antitobacco lobby
 
Snowboarding is more dangerous than skiing
 
Sipping water may not calm exam nerves
 
Bill Gates gives $100m for AIDS vaccine trials
 
Injuries kill over 20 000 children a year in developed countries
 
Write a response to this article
   

Snowboarding is more dangerous than skiing

Snowboarders are more than twice as likely as skiers to sustain serious injuries, and they also tend to be injured more often, according to research published in the Western Journal of Medicine (2001;174:128-31).

The research shows that snowboarders are more than twice as likely as skiers to sustain serious fractures, become concussed and lose consciousness, dislocate their joints, and have their teeth knocked out.

The most common injuries tend to be sprains, fractures, cuts, and bruising. One in five of all injuries and half of all fractures involve the wrists, as snowboarders overextend their arms to balance a fall in the absence of ski poles.


AP PHOTO/CAMAY SUNGU

Originally introduced in the 1920s, snowboarding is now one of the fastest growing winter sports in the world. Over 13 million visits were made, by 3.3m snowboarders, to ski resorts in the United States last year.

The typical profile of a snowboarder is of a young man, often with no skiing experience and no training. But Dr Kathleen Dunn, author of the research and director of the Injury Control Center in New York, said, "The sport is becoming very mainstream, with a lot of adults taking it up."

Safety guidelines for snowboarders
  • Get formal training in proper snowboarding techniques
  • Pick the right time and place to learn (good weather, uncrowded slope, soft groomed snow)
  • Wear protective gear (helmet, goggles, wrist guards)
  • Wear insulated, waterproofed, and layered clothing
  • Protect exposed skin with sunscreen with high sun protection factor (SPF)
  • Snowboard with a buddy trained in first aid and cardiopulmonary resuscitation
  • Snowboard on patrolled areas, not on ungroomed trails or in wooded areas
  • Preprogramme your telephone with the ski patrol number
  • Be aware of your location at all times to guide rescue efforts if needed
  • Don't use drugs or alcohol when snowboarding
(Western Journal of Medicine 2001;174:128-31)

The research shows that snowboarders prefer street clothes rather than protective skiwear, so they are at greater risk of hypothermia and sunburn. And few wear helmets. Head injury is rare, but the risk is double that of skiers, while the risk of spinal injury is four times as high. One in 10 snowboarders will sustain permanent neurological damage. Fast speeds and off piste activity increase the risk of injuries from rocks and other hard objects, according to a spokesperson for the Ski Club of Great Britain.

A recent two year study of snowboarding during the winter olympics in the Journal of Trauma (1999; 46: 1066-9) reported 143 head injuries, of which nine were serious and three led to permanent damage. None of the snowboarders was wearing a helmet.

Responsibility code
  • Always stay in control and be able to stop or avoid other people or objects
  • People ahead of you have the right of way. It is your responsibility to avoid them
  • You must not stop where you obstruct a trail or are not visible from above
  • Whenever starting downhill or merging into a trail, look uphill and yield to others
  • Always use devices to help prevent runaway equipment
  • Observe all posted signs and warnings. Keep off closed trails and out of closed areas
  • Before using any lift, you must have the ability to load, ride, and unload safely
(Western Journal of Medicine 2001;174:128-31)

"The difficulty is getting manufacturers to make helmets cool enough for kids to wear. But we've done it with cycles, so perhaps it will be easier to do this in snowboarding," Dr Dunn said.

Formal training is vital, says Dr Dunn, and many ski resorts now offer snowboarding for beginners. "The right clothing, protective gear, and high sun protection factor should help to minimise the risk of injury," she said, "and it is better to keep off drugs and alcohol while snowboarding." Useful websites: www.skiclub.co.uk, www.ski-injury.com


Caroline White London