Reviews    Please click the Current Issue button above to return to the contents page
 
The Devil's Gardens: A History of Landmines
 
Lucky Man
 
Secret Agents: The Menace of Emerging Infections
 
Sci45 Speciality Choice Inventory
 
Grossology: the (impolite) science of the human body
 
An Australian x ray
 
Why voluntary work overseas is a must
 
Minerva
 
Write a response to this article
   

An Australian x ray

Australias Aboriginal population is overlooked when it comes to health care. Lilijana Mikuletic felt she needed to find out more and was dismayed with what she learnt

Its like when you are asked to describe an x ray and you see a significant blob: you know it really is important, but you dont know what it means. That was what my education in the health of Australias Aboriginal population was like. Sometimes it would be obvious and spoken about in cold hard facts, and I would feel guilty. But most of the time it was shadowy and uncertain. A brief mention in a lecture, maybe a passing comment by a statistician. It resembled an undifferentiated tumour that everyone found hard to talk about because its management was too complex.

As an Australian medical student I was meant to understand the facts “life expectancy 19 years lower than the rest,” and “unacceptable infant mortality.” But growing up in a major city I had little contact with our Aboriginal population and am ashamed to say that I never took steps to try to understand.

Frustrated with my ignorance, I made moves to gain some perspective. In December last year I left the comforts of my existence in Sydney and found myself stepping off a tiny plane onto the sands of the Western Desert. This region, the Pilbara, forms part of the rugged landscape of far north Western Australia (see map). Here I was thrown headfirst into Aboriginal Australia.

First, let me describe the environment. It is incredibly hot (40°C average), dry, dusty (thousands of kilometres of dirt road), few trees, and precipitation a distant idea. And people live here.

Punmu, a community of 150, was my residence. The Martu Aboriginal people here speak Manyjiljarra as their first language and are acknowledged as the last of Australias Aboriginal groups to encounter Europeans, in the late 1960s. They were moved from the area to return later in the 1980s. This is a highly traditional cultural enclave: they live by ancient law, hunt local game, and participate in traditional rituals.

My role was to help in the medical clinic. Here, I had to deal with a multitude of health problems that would face a health worker in any developing country. Scabies, otitis media, and boils were commonplace, with syphilis and trachoma waiting in the wings. Then there was diabetes. The town has one store, stocked with tinned food and sweets, but no fresh fruit or vegetables. It would take too much organisation to stock the weekly mail plane with these non-pharmacological treatments.

The result? The people really are in crisis (those lecturers were not lying). The good intentions of Europeans to create a welfare state—provision of homes, infrastructure, education—has created a people who have no role, no real need to think or plan. They have become institutionalised. As a result a distinct feel of hopelessness and lack of motivation prevails.

The examples are numerous. During my stay I saw the arrival of a new house, a culturally inappropriate prefabricated home that was driven in to the community over the dusty country miles. Are these people incapable of building their own homes?

I do not wish to debate the reasons for these problems nor list solutions. This has been done many times. I will, however, share my lasting impression. These people have so lost control over their lives that they have lost all motivation or drive to function. In trying to help, the government has made these people prisoners. Why not let them build their own homes? Not only would it empower Aboriginal people to take control, it would be much cheaper for the government. This is one of many critical questions that we should be debating for future change.

My concern is that doctors, policy makers, and others who influence the Aboriginal health arena do not always have a true appreciation of the situation. This can come only from first-hand experience, by talking a plunge into the world of our most needy group. This means talking to Aboriginal people, eating with them, managing their health problems, seeing how disease affects their lives. Such a commitment is not always easy, but doctors need to take some responsibility if things are to change.

So now I am back home, studying for finals, and hoping my radiology skills are practised enough to ensure I do not miss any critical pathology in my exams. But what I am most certain of is that if questioned on Aboriginal health issues I will not need to order a scan by magnetic resonance imaging.


Lilijana Mikuletic fourth year medical studentUniversity of Sydney, Australia
lil@gmp.usyd.edu.au

Rapid Responses:

Read all Rapid Responses

Respond to this article







PENNY TWEEDIE/PANOS PICTURES

We can only influence Aboriginal health through first-hand experience