ABC of heart failure: Non-drug management
C R Gibbs, G Jackson, G Y H Lip
Approaches to the management of heart failure can be both non-pharmacological
and pharmacological; each approach complements the other. This article
will discuss non-pharmacological management.
Counselling and education of patients
Effective counselling and education of patients, and of the relatives
or carers, is important and may enhance long term adherence to management
strategies. Simple explanations about the symptoms and signs of
heart failure, including details on drug and other treatment strategies,
are valuable. Emphasis should be placed on self help strategies
for each patient; these should include information on the need to
adhere to drug treatment. Some patients can be instructed how to
monitor their weight at home on a daily basis and how to adjust
the dose of diuretics as advised; sudden weight increases (>2
kg in 1-3 days), for example, should alert a patient to alter his
or her treatment or seek advice.
Non-pharmacological
measures for the management of heart failure
- Compliance-give careful advice about disease, treatment,
and self help strategies
- Diet-ensure adequate general nutrition and, in obese
patients, weight reduction
- Salt-advise patients to avoid high salt content foods
and not to add salt (particularly in severe cases of congestive
heart failure)
- Fluid-urge overloaded patients and those with severe
congestive heart failure to restrict their fluid intake
- Alcohol-advise moderate alcohol consumption (abstinence
in alcohol related cardiomyopathy)
- Smoking-avoid smoking (adverse effects on coronary disease,
adverse haemodynamic effects)
- Exercise-regular exercise should be encouraged
- Vaccination-patients should consider influenza and pneumococcal
vaccinations
Lifestyle measures
Urging patients to alter their lifestyle is important in the management
of chronic heart failure. Social activities should be encouraged,
however, and care should be taken to ensure that patients avoid
social isolation. If possible, patients should continue their regular
work, with adaptations to accommodate a reduced physical capacity
where appropriate.

Self help strategies for patients with heart
failure
Contraceptive advice
Advice on contraception should be offered to women of childbearing
potential, particularly those patients with advanced heart failure
(class III-IV in the New York Heart Association's classification),
in whom the risk of maternal morbidity and mortality is high with
pregnancy and childbirth. Current hormonal contraceptive methods
are much safer than in the past: low dose oestrogen and third generation
progestogen derivatives are associated with a relatively low thromboembolic
risk.
Intrauterine
devices are a suitable form of contraception, although these
may be a problem in patients with primary valvar disease,
in view of the risks of infection and risks associated with
oral anticoagulation
Menopausal women
with heart failure
- Observational data indicate that hormone replacement
therapy reduces the risk of coronary events in postmenopausal
women
- However, there is limited prospective evidence to advise
the use of such therapy in postmenopausal women with heart
failure
- Nevertheless, there may be an increased risk of venous
thrombosis in postmenopausal women taking hormone replacement
therapy, which may exacerbate the risk associated with
heart failure
Smoking
Cigarette smoking should be strongly discouraged in patients with
heart failure. In addition to the well established adverse effects
on coronary disease, which is the underlying cause in a substantial
proportion of patients, smoking has adverse haemodynamic effects
in patients with congestive heart failure. For example, smoking
tends to reduce cardiac output, especially in patients with a history
of myocardial infarction.
Other adverse haemodynamic effects include an increase in heart
rate and systemic blood pressure (double product) and mild increases
in pulmonary artery pressure, ventricular filling pressures, and
total systemic and pulmonary vascular resistance.
The peripheral vasoconstriction may contribute to the observed
mild reduction in stroke volume, and thus smoking increases oxygen
demand and also decreases myocardial oxygen supply owing to reduced
diastolic filling time (with faster heart rates) and increased carboxyhaemoglobin
concentrations.
Community and
social support
- Community support is particularly important for elderly
or functionally restricted patients with chronic heart
failure
- Support may help to improve the quality of life and
reduce admission rates
- Social services support and community based interventions,
with advice and assistance for close relatives, are also
important
Alcohol
In general, alcohol consumption should be restricted to moderate
levels, given the myocardial depressant properties of alcohol. In
addition to the direct toxic effects of alcohol on the myocardium,
a high alcohol intake predisposes to arrhythmias (especially atrial
fibrillation) and hypertension and may lead to important alterations
in fluid balance. The prognosis in alcohol induced cardiomyopathy
is poor if consumption continues, and abstinence should be advised.
Abstinence can result in marked improvements, with echocardiographic
studies showing substantial clinical benefit and improvements in
left ventricular function. Resumed alcohol consumption may subsequently
lead to acute or worsening heart failure.
Immunisation and antiobiotic prophylaxis
Chronic heart failure predisposes to and can be exacerbated by
pulmonary infection, and influenza and pneumococcal vaccinations
should therefore be considered in all patients with heart failure.
Antibiotic prophylaxis, for dental and other surgical procedures,
is mandatory in patients with primary valve disease and prosthetic
heart valves.
Managing cachexia
in chronic heart failure
Combined management by physician and dietician is recommended
- Alter size and frequency of meals
- Ensure a higher energy diet
- Supplement diet with (a) water soluble vitamins
(loss associated with diuresis), (b) fat soluble
vitamins (levels reduced as a result of poor absorption),
and (c) fish oils

Heart failure cooperation card: patients
and doctors
are able to monitor changes in clinical signs (including
weight),
drug treatment, and baseline investigations. Patients should
be
encouraged to monitor their weight between clinic visits
Diet and nutrition
Although controlled trials offer only limited information on diet
and nutritional measures, such measures are as important in heart
failure, as in any other chronic illness, to ensure adequate and
appropriate nutritional balance. Poor nutrition may contribute to
cardiac cachexia, although malnutrition is not limited to patients
with obvious weight loss and muscle wasting.
Patients with chronic heart failure are at an increased risk from
malnutrition owing to (a) a decreased intake resulting from
a poor appetite, which may be related to drug treatment (for example,
aspirin, digoxin), metabolic disturbance (for example, hyponatraemia
or renal failure), or hepatic congestion; (b) malabsorption,
particularly in patients with severe heart failure; and (c)
increased nutritional requirements, with patients who have congestive
heart failure having an increase of up to 20% in basal metabolic
rate. These factors may contribute to a net catabolic state where
lean muscle mass is reduced, leading to an increase in symptoms
and reduced exercise capacity. Indeed, cardiac cachexia is an independent
risk factor for mortality in patients with chronic heart failure.
A formal nutritional assessment should thus be considered in those
patients who appear to have a poor nutritional state.
Weight loss in obese patients should be encouraged as excess body
mass increases cardiac workload during exercise. Weight reduction
in obese patients to within 10% of the optimal body weight
should be encouraged.
Commonly consumed
processed foods that have a high sodium content
- Cheese
- Sausages
- Crisps, salted peanuts
- Milk and white chocolate
- Tinned soup and tinned vegetables
- Ham, bacon, tinned meat (eg, corned beef)
- Tinned fish (eg, sardines, salmon, tuna)
- Smoked fish
Fresh produce, such as fruit,
vegetables, eggs, and fish, has a relatively low salt content
Salt restriction
No randomised studies have addressed the role of salt restriction
in congestive heart failure. Nevertheless restriction to about 2
g of sodium a day may be useful as an adjunct to treatment with
high dose diuretics, particularly if the condition is advanced.
In general, patients should be advised that they should avoid foods
that are rich in salt and not to add salt to their food at the table.
Fluid intake
Fluid restriction (1.5-2 litres daily) should be considered in patients
with severe symptoms, those requiring high dose diuretics, and those
with a tendency towards excessive fluid intake. High fluid intake
negates the positive effects of diuretics and induces hyponatraemia.
Exercise training and rehabilitation
Exercise training has been shown to benefit patients with heart
failure: patients show an improvement in symptoms, a greater sense
of wellbeing, and better functional capacity. Exercise does not,
however, result in obvious improvement in cardiac function.
 |
| Effects
of deconditioning in heart failure |
| Peripheral alterations |
Increased peripheral
vascular resistance; impaired oxygen utilisation during exercise |
| Abnormalities of
autonomic control |
Enhanced sympathetic
activation; vagal withdrawal; reduced baroreflex sensitivity |
| Skeletal muscle abnormalities |
Reduced mass and
composition |
| Reduced functional
capacity |
Reduced exercise
tolerance; reduced peak oxygen consumption |
| Psychological effects |
Reduced activity;
reduced overall sense of wellbeing |
 |
All stable patients with heart failure should be encouraged to
participate in a supervised, simple exercise programme. Although
bed rest ("armchair treatment") may be appropriate in patients with
acute heart failure, regular exercise should be encouraged in patients
with chronic heart failure. Indeed, chronic immobility may result
in loss of muscle mass in the lower limbs and generalised physical
deconditioning, leading to a further reduction in exercise capacity
and a predisposition to thromboembolism. Deconditioning itself may
be detrimental, with peripheral alterations and central abnormalities
leading to vasoconstriction, further deterioration in left ventricular
function, and greater reduction in functional capacity.

Exercise class for group of patients with
heart failure (published with permission of participants)
Importantly, regular exercise has the potential to slow or stop
this process and exert beneficial effects on the autonomic profile,
with reduced sympathetic activity and enhanced vagal tone, thus
reversing some of the adverse consequences of heart failure. Large
prospective clinical trials will establish whether these beneficial
effects improve prognosis and reduce the incidence of sudden death
in patients with chronic heart failure.
Beneficial
effects of exercise in chronic heart failure
Has positive effects on:
- Skeletal muscle
- Autonomic function
- Endothelial function
- Neurohormonal function
- Insulin sensitivity
No positive effects on survival have been shown
Regular exercise should therefore be advocated in stable patients
as there is the potential for improvements in exercise tolerance
and quality of life, without deleterious effects on left ventricular
function. Cardiac rehabilitation services offer benefit to this
group, and patients should be encouraged to develop their own regular
exercise routine, including walking, cycling, and swimming. Nevertheless,
patients should know their limits, and excessive fatigue or breathlessness
should be avoided. In the first instance, a structured walking programme
would be the easiest to adopt.
Treatment of underlying disease
Treatment should also be aimed at slowing or reversing any underlying
disease process.
Hypertension
Good blood pressure control is essential, and angiotensin converting
enzyme inhibitors are the drugs of choice in patients with impaired
systolic function, in view of their beneficial effects on slowing
disease progression and improving prognosis. In cases of isolated
diastolic dysfunction, either ² blockers or calcium channel
blockers with rate limiting properties-for example, verapamil, diltiazem-have
theoretical advantages. If severe left ventricular hypertrophy is
the cause of diastolic dysfunction, however, an angiotensin converting
enzyme inhibitor may be more effective at inducing regression of
left ventricular hypertrophy. Angiotensin II receptor antagonists
should be considered as an alternative if cough that is induced
by angiotensin converting enzyme inhibitors is problematic.

M mode echocardiogram
showing left ventricular hypertrophy in hypertensive patient
(A=interventricular septum; B=posterior wall of left ventricle)
Surgery
If coronary heart disease is the underlying cause of chronic heart
failure and if cardiac ischaemia is present, the patient may benefit
from coronary revascularisation, including coronary angioplasty
or coronary artery bypass grafting. Revascularisation may also improve
the function of previously hibernating myocardium. Valve replacement
or valve repair should be considered in patients with haemodynamically
important primary valve disease.
 |
| Role
of surgery in heart failure |
| Type of surgery |
Reason |
| Coronary revascularisation
(PTCA, CABG) |
Angina, reversible
ischaemia, hibernating myocardium |
| Valve replacement
(or repair) |
Significant valve
disease (aortic stenosis, mitral regurgitation) |
| Permanent pacemakers
and implantable cardiodefibrillators |
Bradycardias; resistant
ventricular arrhythmias |
| Cardiac transplantation |
End stage heart failure
|
| Ventricular assist
devices |
Short term ventricular
support-eg, awaiting transplantation |
| Novel surgical techniques |
Limited role (high
mortality, limited evidence of substantial benefit) |
 |
| PTCA=percutaneous
transluminal coronary angioplasty; CABG=coronary artery bypass
graft. |
Cardiac transplantation is now established as the treatment of
choice for some patients with severe heart failure who remain symptomatic
despite intensive medical treatment. It is associated with a one
year survival of about 90% and a 10 year survival of 50-60%,
although it is limited by the availability of donor organs. Transplantation
should be considered in younger patients (aged <60 years) who
are without severe concomitant disease (for example, renal failure
or malignancy).

Electrocardiogram
showing left ventricular hypertrophy on voltage criteria, with
associated T wave and ST changes in the lateral leads ("strain
pattern")
Bradycardias are managed with conventional permanent cardiac pacing,
although a role is emerging for biventricular cardiac pacing in
some patients with resistant severe congestive heart failure. Implantable
cardiodefibrillators are well established in the treatment of some
patients with resistant life threatening ventricular arrhythmias.
New surgical approaches such as cardiomyoplasty and ventricular
reduction surgery (Batista procedure) are rarely used owing to the
high associated morbidity and mortality and the lack of conclusive
trial evidence of substantial benefit.
Key references
- Demakis JG, Proskey A, Rahimtoola SH, Jamil M, Sutton
GC, Rosen KM, et al. The natural course of alcoholic cardiomyopathy.
Ann Intern Med 1974;80:293-7.
- The Task Force of the Working Group on Heart Failure
of the European Society of Cardiology. Guidelines on the
treatment of heart failure. Eur Heart J 1997;18:736-53.
- Kostis JB, Rosen RC, Cosgrove NM, Shindler DM, Wilson
AC. Nonpharmacologic therapy improves functional and emotional
status in congestive heart failure. Chest 1994;106:996-1001.
- McKelvie RS, Teo KK, McCartney N, Humen D, Montague
T, Yusuf S. Effects of exercise training in patients with
congestive heart failure: a critical review. J Am Coll
Cardiol 1995;25:789-96.
The box about managing cachexia is based on recommendations from the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network
(SIGN) (publication No 35, 1999).
G Jackson, consultant cardiologist, the department of cardiology, Guy's and St Thomas's Hospital, London.
The ABC of heart failure is edited by C R Gibbs, M K Davies, and G Y H Lip.
CRG is research fellow and GYHL is consultant cardiologist and reader in medicine in the university department of medicine and the department of cardiology, City Hospital, Birmingham; MKD is consultant cardiologist in the department of cardiology, Selly Oak Hospital, Birmingham. The series will be published as a book in the spring.
studentBMJ 2000;08:131-174 May ISSN 0966-6494