Vigor Mortis
Kate
Berridge
Profile, 2002,
£7.99
ISBN
1 86197 411
6
Rating:
****
Just
as causes of death have changed dramatically over the past centuries,
so have the ways in which we deal with the dead. Berridges book
is well written and very entertaining, in spite of the subject
matter.
Berridge shows
that our attitude to mortal remains is as much at the whim of fashion
and the vagaries of historical accident, as any other part of our
lives. She describes, for example, the connection between the killing
fields of the first world war and the end of the Victorian practice of
prolonged public mourning, clad in
black.
We follow the
slow rise of cremation through city population booms, body snatching,
public health concerns, and the considerable influence of the funeral
choices of a fashionable few, to its position today as the preferred
method of body disposal.
Much of the
book concerns contemporary behaviour, including the return of mass
public displays of grief, peaking with the death of Diana (but
triggered following the football stadium disasters of the 1980s and
1990s). A very interesting comparison is made between the public
reaction to Dianas death and that of another
peoples princess, Princess Charlotte, who died in
1817 while trying to deliver a future
king.
There is a lively,
up-beat, if not to say anti-establishment discussion of
current funeral practices and options. Berridge has obviously retained
her journalistic skill at getting in among those she wants to write
about. She has attended conferences and exhibitions and even got
herself on a panel choosing the best kept graveyard in Britain. She
strongly supports (but does not evangelise) the return of funeral
arrangements to the hands of the
family.
As a preregistration house
officer, certifying death soon becomes just another job on your endless
to do list. We rapidly forget, perhaps necessarily so, the disruption
we have just officially triggered in the lives of those more
permanently affected by the death. Funerals are an important part of
the grieving process and are for the living, not for the dead. This
book would certainly be more informative to the bereaved than the
po-faced leaflets on What to do when someone
dies.
Ben Mills, senior house officer, Royal Army Medical Corps, Frimley Park Hospital
Email: benmills@ecosse.net
studentBMJ 2002;10:171-214 June ISSN 0966-6494