skip navigation
student.bmj.com

Epileptic 1

David B

LAssociation, 2002, $24.95, pp 160

ISBN 2 844 14085 8

Rating: ****

David Bs Epileptic 1 is a comic book like no other. It provides a rare insight into the world of epilepsy and perhaps, more importantly, gives the reader a glimpse of the frustration and anxiety this illness causes for families. Outstanding drawings interspersed with a chilling commentary bring alive the story of Jean-Christophe, the authors brother.

Set in France, the tale tells of the authors childhood through the 1970s. Drawing the brothers epilepsy in the form of a snake-like monster, the disease raises its head with increasing frequency as Jean-Christophe becomes a teenager. When the dreaded neurosurgeons propose brain surgery as a cure, the family turns to less invasive options. First to be tried is zen macrobiotics, as preached by Master N. But when living in a commune turns out not to be as open minded as they expected, Jean-Christophes parents resort to a whole host of alternatives—from Swedenborgian spiritism to esoterism and absolute structure to psychoanalysis. Sadly, Jean-Christophes epilepsy becomes progressively worse resulting in his institutionalisation.

Epileptic 1 is a superb example of escapism and is entirely consistent with a childs view of the world. It also illustrates the way that the problems of one child affect the development of siblings. Vivid drawings of mythical creatures, Mongol hordes, and household animals provide the young B with solace as he seeks to come to terms with his brothers illness. Combined with black humour at moments of emotional turbulence—as much a sign of Jean-Christophes imagination as of Bs sense of irony—this story is unique. The sense of anguish is all the more pronounced when you consider that the comic is based on original drawings compiled by both brothers from childhood. This anguish is not helped when you see the doctors depicted as dictatorial know it alls; not very patient friendly at all.

Originally written as a six part story, Epileptic 1 comprises the original volumes 1, 2, and 3. Publishers LAssociation, expect to release Epileptic 2 once the sixth and final chapter has been published in France. Provided that the self indulgent, incessant references to French atrocities in Algeria and to the death of David Bs grandfather are curtailed, it should be worth the wait.



Omar Mukhtar, final year medical student, University of Bristol
Email: studentdoctor@hotmail.com


studentBMJ 2003;11:219-262 July ISSN 0966-6494



Previous article    Return to top    Next article
Printer friendly page    Download article PDF    Email this article to a friend