Nip/Tuck
Starts
10 pm on Tuesday 13 January 2004 on Sky One;
www.skyone.co.uk
Rating:****
After
a fierce bidding war, the arrival of the hit US series
Nip/Tuck on British television marks the birth of a new type
of medical drama. Ryan Murphy, creator, says the programme is
"essentially about all of the reasons why we as a society hate
ourselves."
Nominated for
Golden Globes, Nip/Tuck centres around a flourishing
cosmetic surgery practice in Miami and the lives of the two surgeons
who run it. One surgeon is obsessed with sex, normally with his
patients; his colleague is undergoing a mid-life crisis; and an
ethical code seems alien to them both. The series practically
juxtaposes equally graphic scenes of sex and surgery. Plots range from
helping a drug dealer to flee the country by altering his face to
coercing young female patients into the practice. Because of this,
Nip/Tuck has become hugely popular and has polarised
American opinion. Rod Rohrich, president elect of the American Society
of Plastic Surgeons, said: "There's no realism in it at
all. We think it's an abomination of what real plastic surgeons
and true patients do . . . I think about 20 patients have talked to me
about how despicable it was-but of course, they
watched."
British plastic
surgeons have reacted similarly to scenes like the spectacularly
botched liposuction and refusal to treat burnt children. Norman
Waterhouse, consultant plastic surgeon and president of the British
Association of Aesthetic Plastic Surgeons, said: "The show does
not portray the 'real life' world of plastic surgery and,
in fact, does a disservice to millions of patients who benefit from
cosmetic procedures." Judy Evans, also a consultant plastic
surgeon and a member of the association's council, said:
"The show's premise is ghastly. It is difficult enough for
a patient to pluck up the courage to come to see a surgeon in the first
place."
Compared with medical
dramas like ER or Casualty, Nip/Tuck focuses
specifically on one specialty rather than general medicine. Aesthetic
plastic surgery in Miami was an obvious choice for sensational
television. But, just as police dramas have portrayed corrupt cops,
Nip/Tuck simply presents a dark side to doctors, without
implying reality. The series explores the breathtakingly painful
extremes to which patients are willing to go for beautiful bodies and
points the finger at our shallow society as the cause of this
desperation. Nip/Tuck is a reflection of how, in the eyes of
many, looks are of the utmost importance and plastic surgery merely a
means to an end. Nip/Tuck is compelling, if at times
horrifying, viewing, but if you remember that the stories are
fictional, this adventurous series is hugely entertaining; after all,
where else could you see a plastic surgeon driving a
speedboat called the Boatox?
Rohin Francis, third year medical student, St George's Hospital Medical School, London
Email: guptastar@yahoo.com
studentBMJ 2004;12:45-88 February ISSN 0966-6494