How to choose finals revision courses
Carol Kan and Suresh Krishnan speak from experience
It’s that time of year again when all the final years start what seems like their never ending revision for the dreaded MB
BS (bachelor of medicine and surgery) finals. The good thing is that most people pass and become doctors. But how do you survive
the period ahead?
One puzzle is how to choose a revision course. You are swamped by letters and emails from all sorts of organisations promoting
their courses, which all sound similar on paper but are often quite different.
National or local
The Medical Defence Union, the Medical Protection Society, and Pastest run national courses from London to Glasgow in medicine,
surgery, and other specialties, including paediatrics. They provide a comprehensive grounding in the basics, with handouts
containing useful mnemonics and revision guides. The teachers are consummate professionals and, as most of them are examiners,
they can highlight the common pitfalls encountered in the exams and provide tips on how to avoid them. These courses can,
however, be expensive, ranging from £50 to £250 (€70 to €340; $100 to $500).
Local courses provided by the hospitals in your university are tailored more towards your needs because they tend to be based
on your curriculum. They are also likely to take place in your local area, and so commuting is not a problem. It is important
to bear this in mind because travelling can add additional stress to your already jam packed revision schedule. The quality
and organisation of local courses can vary tremendously, and finding information about them can be hard. A good way to find
out more is to visit your university’s website, to contact relevant university societies, and to talk to friends who have
just completed finals.
Theory or practical
Most revision courses teach clinical theory, with limited practical exposure. An increasing number of medical schools are
using the objective structured clinical examination format for the practical aspects of examinations, and there has been a
corresponding rise in local courses that cater for such an approach. Our opinion is that the practical elements of clinical
medicine are better developed by organising weekly tutorials with a doctor (from senior house officers to consultants—anyone
who has passed their membership exams for one of the royal colleges of physicians or surgeons), in which you examine patients
and discuss appropriate clinical cases.
Your university may already have a system in place to facilitate this, or you may need to arrange it yourself—but you won’t
know if you don’t ask. We recommend that for everyone to participate fully and gain maximum benefit the ideal scenario for
revision tutorials would be groups of 3-5 students for 1-2 hours each week.
Weekend or weekly
For some courses you can attend a weekend or weekly session—that is, three hours once a week. The advantages of a weekend
course are that it gives a quick review of what you do and do not know and that is easier to fit into a busy schedule. They
are, however, extremely intense, and retaining information can be difficult in the eight hour marathon.
Weekly courses are excellent because they cover topics over time, which is more likely to help reinforce your understanding
of the subject. You are invariably given a course schedule on the first day, and preparing for the topics beforehand will
benefit. However, weekly courses are a lot more expensive than weekend courses, and making the commitment can be difficult
to organise in your life. It may also interfere with your revision plan, as they tend to cover a few specific topics each
week, and this timetable of revision may be different to your own.
Flying colours
Remember that a revision course is not a golden ticket to passing finals. Most are crash courses that cover the essentials
for MB BS examinations—the aim is to help you pass. They should be thought of as tools to help you with revision, but no more.
Some people attend every course under the sun and still fail, and others attend none and pass with flying colours.
Everyone has their own individual learning needs and will respond best to different revision methods, be it lectures, group
teaching, or individual study. You need to identify which is best for you. Your university will also organise its own courses,
and they are worth asking about. Despite all these revision aids, sometimes you’ll find yourself just having to sit down and
learn the many causes of pleural effusion.
General tips
- Treat a revision course as a study aid rather than comprehensive preparation
- Don’t attend many courses on the same subject out of fear of failing
- Use courses to guide your revision and highlight important topics
- Choose a revision course that will target your own academic weaknesses
- Ask seniors, friends, and relevant university bodies to identify appropriate revision courses
- If doing week long courses, prepare for each session—you will get more out of it
- Supplement the theory learnt on the course with history taking, examination, and clinical skills practice
- Factor time for travelling into your decision
- Don’t become stressed if you find you are unfamiliar with material discussed in a course—it is as important to find out what
you don’t know as what you do know
- There is no substitute for getting your head down and learning the material
Competing interests: None declared.
Provenance and peer review: Commissioned; not externally peer reviewed.
Carol Kan F2 1North West Foundation Programme
Suresh Krishnan F1 2South East Foundation Programme
Email: carolkan@doctors.org.uk
Student BMJ 2008;16:115 | 17
|
CAREERS
How to choose finals revision courses
(Carol Kan and Suresh Krishnan, March 2008)
|
|
dr avinash aujayeb (April 7th, 2008)
Speciality trainee 1, Queen Elizabeth Hospital,Gateshead aujayeb@doctors.net.uk
|
|
|
Dear authors, I read your article with great interest and particularly liked the bit you wrote that a revision course is not a golden ticket for passing the examinations. As someone who has recently passed his PACES and only done a course for that (money constraints not permitting before), I can testify to the fact that if one gets a good revision programme organised by a certain education centre or a very good clinical tutor, then that obviates the need for a course. All you need is constant practice and the wards can be the best books and one's senior colleagues the best teachers.
|
|
|